Thoughts (sociological and geographical)
on urban space, identity, culture, and design.
May 17, 2012
More on Neighborhood Identity
Most broadly, the excellent This Big City blog ran a great story (and related #citytalk session) a couple of months ago that discussed the different characters of different cities and how citizens both define and are defined by their cities' identity. Here's the piece: Urban Identity: Citizens and Their Cities
In terms of neighborhood identity specifically, I loved this New York Times article on a part of Manhattan's Upper West Side that "needs a name". This basic concept of a neighborhood without clear identity has been a fascinating one to me for years - part of the inspiration for my research on the role that transit design can play in promoting identity in areas that lack it, and is very similar to my project on a "neighborhood without a name" in Chicago (which ultimately became an article on the culture of first-wave gentrification in "fringe" areas). Much like Chicago (and unlike L.A.), it is surprising to hear about a neighborhood in New York City without a long-established identity. Sure, boundaries shift (due to movement or expansion of defining groups, as in the case of Chinatown, or thanks to overzealous real-estate agents stretching more 'valuable' names into areas on their fringes, as happened with Williamsburg), and new neighborhoods are occasionally even "created" due to re-branding (NoLiTa? SoBro?), but to have an area that is actively unsure of and seeking identity, seemingly out of thin air, is uncommon here - especially in Manhattan. The reason of course is that the neighborhood is actually, physically new - the result of massive new condo development on what used to be railyards between 59th and 72nd streets near the Hudson River. It literally has new streets (including Riverside Boulevard, a name that some are trying to brand the whole area with), few restaurants or attractions, and is - perhaps crucially - beyond the delivery areas of many of those that cover the rest of the Upper West Side. Yet it has some 8,000 residents. A great read: All This Neighborhood Needs is a Name.
Finally, more recently, I've come across two fascinating posts on the actual defining and mapping of urban areas. First, MIT Technology Review reported on a project called Livehoods from Carnegie Mellon researchers that ingeniously uses Foursquare 'check-in' data to measure "social proximity" in different parts of cities (currently Pittsburgh, NYC, and the Bay Area). It reminds me of the "Neighborhood Project" over at theory.org, which uses craigslist data to similar effect. Interestingly though, the Livelihoods folks code each area with numbers rather than names, because the data provide none (though they're considering crowd-sourcing the actual names at a later date, a bit like the LA Times did for its Mapping LA Neighborhoods project). Here's the article: Using Foursquare Data to Redefine a Neighborhood. Meanwhile, James Cheshire of UCL's Centre for Advanced Spatial Statistics gave a presentation on the subject of Mapping London's Population Flows, the results of which were posted on the SpatialAnalysis.co.uk blog. Cheshire considers the use of data such as surnames (see below), transport trips, twitter traffic, etc. to map the way people live and use different parts of the city.
May 10, 2012
Harvard Political Review article on 'Mapping Babel'
Apr 17, 2012
"Lefebvre and Whyte Hit the Streets"
Lefebvre and Whyte Hit the Streets
The Diffusion of Scholarly Urbanism and the Rise of the Informal Urban Designer
There are numerous ways in which people make illegal or unauthorized alterations to urban space, its uses, or meanings. This paper is based on my research into a particular type of spatial intervention: creative, highly localized, and largely anonymous practices aimed explicitly at “improving” particular aspects of the built environment without permission. Examples include people painting their own crosswalks and bicycle lanes, gardening vacant lots and public spaces, building and installing benches and other street furniture, or creating faux-official signage to promote desired civic improvements or commemorate unheralded events – what I call “do-it-yourself urban design.” We all have our assumptions about the meanings of these types of things, who makes them, why, and where, and they raise questions of context, rights, responsibilities, and perhaps unintended consequences. To that end, this paper presents one of the more unexpected and potentially significant findings - the degree to which many members of this group of informal placemakers are in fact informed by quite sophisticated knowledge of planning, design, and academic urbanism. Building from qualitative fieldwork and interviews with individuals in nine cities, I show how the ideas of professional planning and design and scholarly urban theory feature in the work of do-it-yourself urban designers. I argue that this knowledge inspires their actions, informs their justifications, and produces a self-reflexivity on their parts that at once emboldens them and raises personal ethical dilemmas about unintended consequences.
Mar 28, 2012
"Cultural Expectations and Urban Development: The Roll of 'Cultural Sensitivity' and 'Cultural Sincerity' in Local Growth Politics"
The article, "Cultural Expectations and Urban Development," presents my research into the ways that local culture influences so-called "growth machine" development. Through case studies of the politics surrounding two recent development proposals in Davis, California, I show that the unique character, identity, and normative expectations of a community are not always as irrelevant to large 'outside' development actors as they are thought to be. In particular, I argue that the Target Corporation's attention to local expectations of unique small-town charm and leadership in environmental sustainability paid an important role in their ability to win voter approval for a (first ever) 'big box' store in this vocally 'anti-corporate' community. By contrasting this victory with the failure a year earlier of an ostensibly 'green' and even quite locally-based housing development, I show how both cultural sensitivity and perceived sincerity are instrumental to success.
Here's the abstract and citation for the article. It can be accessed here if you have jstor access, or here if you don't (pdf).
Cultural Expectations and Urban Development: The Roll of 'Cultural Sensitivity' and 'Cultural Sincerity' in Local Growth Politics
This article examines the role of culture in the local urban development process through a case study of recent proposals in Davis, California. The author argues that community cultural expectations—of environmental leadership and the preservation of local character—had an important impact on project proposals and the political campaigns
that followed, including the ability of an unlikely corporate developer to win public approval from this town with a vocal and usually powerful anti-corporate character. While on the surface the local growth coalition came together as expected in the literature, this study demonstrates that development organizations operate within cultural contexts that are more complex than the existing discourse has accounted for. Factors that the author calls “cultural sensitivity” and “cultural sincerity” both play a role. As concerns with environmental sustainability and preservation of local character gain prominence in development politics, the insights drawn from these cases are of particular value.
Douglas, Gordon C. C. "Cultural Expectations and Urban Development: The Roll of 'Cultural Sensitivity' and 'Cultural Sincerity' in Local Growth Politics," Sociological Perspectives, vol. 55, no. 1, March 2012. 213-236.
Mar 20, 2012
Forthcoming Article on Fringe Gentrification and Subultural Ideologies of "the Edge"
The article, "The Edge of the Island: Cultural Ideology and Neighborhood Identity at the Gentrification Frontier", presents the results of my research in an area in Chicago's West Town community area that I call "Edgetown." I conducted a land-use survey, key informant interviews, and media analysis to examine this "neighborhood without a name" and the cultural ideals that drive the first hip gentrifiers away from trendier areas and into undefined edgespaces such as this. I argue that they are driven by the search for a romanticized ideal of the pre-gentrified edge itself, even though they largely recognize that their very movement brings further gentrification with it.
Feb 26, 2012
AAG 2012
This afternoon I'm really looking forward to the panel on Parsing the Politics and Practice of 'DIY' that I organized with my friends and colleagues Brian Hracs of the University of Toronto and Uppsala University, and Michael Seman of U.T. Arlington. As we write in the abstract, the panel will "bring together an interdisciplinary group of scholars to discuss the evolution of the term and its value as a topic of conceptual and empirical inquiry. Drawing on studies of music, art, fashion, cycling culture and urban revitalization the panelists will unpack the intersections between alternative identities and practices and how activities associated with D.I.Y. shape, and are shaped by, local spaces and scenes." Our excellent panel also includes: Patrick Adler (UCLA), Alison Bain (York), Dan Campo (Morgan State), Doreen Jakob (Exeter), and Johan Jansson (Uppsala).
Then, on Tuesday morning, I'll be presenting my most recent findings from my dissertation research on DIY urban design in talk entitled "Don't Wait for Anybody to Give you Permission: Unauthorized Urban Design 'Contributions' in the Contemporary City". It will be part of a great-sounding session on "Locating Alternative Geographies Through the Spatial Imaginary" organized by Ingrid Butler and Asha Best. The abstract can be found here.
Feb 24, 2012
El Urbanismo Informal de Ciudad Mexico
On the one hand, as a dynamic and international 'global city,' hip cultural scenes and world-class architecture and design thinking set the stage for excellent examples of the sort of high-concept unauthorized improvements seen in L.A., Toronto, and London. Groups like Haz Ciudad - formed in large part by professional designers and planners - have embraced the concept of 'wikiciudad', the idea that anyone can edit and modify cities (see this excellent piece by my friend Jimena).
Here, Haz Ciudad's "wikilane" near the Mercado Jamaica in del. Venustiano Carranza has stayed put for months and become part of the fabric of everyday life in the neighborhood.
Here, a couple of community members simply repave their street in a hillside neighborhood of Xochimilco. And below, an informal settlement and bodega constructed along a public bike path in Tlalpan.
Muchísimas gracias a todos en Isla Urbana y mis increíbles guías turísticos y compañeros de ciclismo Jimena y Oscar! Hasta la próxima!(These are just a few favorites. If you feel like sifting through the less relevant stuff, please check out this album for much more DF.)
Jan 27, 2012
More on Neighborhood Identity, Branding, and Real-Estate
orkposters London map from orkposters.com via Lee WilshireNeighborhood identity is a favorite subject of mine, especially its connection with urban redevelopment, civic identity efforts, real-estate promotion, and other intentional naming or "branding" efforts. I've written myself on the impact of transit identification planning on neighborhood identity and the influence of cultural identity on local development politics, and earlier this month was quoted in a wonderful Atlantic Cities piece on the subject of neighborhood naming (see also previous post).
Well, a great little Londonist post today strikes right at many of these themes. As the piece's author John rather eloquently puts it:
Too right! He even goes on to note, as I too suggest in my article on the topic(pdf), that "the only time London place names actually seem to change is when a station gets an odd name." Best of all, the ever-diligent Londonist staffers have gone to the length of "track[ing] down these painful formulations, and com[ing] up with some sort of taxonomy." So this is my favorite Londonist post ever. If I may quote at length:London’s place names have always been fluid. Old names are squeezed out by the new and, without fixed borders to work from, your views on where one place ends and another begins are as likely to be about age and class as they are about geography.
All the same, though, deliberate attempts at rebranding are, like most things to do with marketing, horrible, and whenever they start popping up in the papers, we tend to suspect someone enterprising hack is trying to sell their flat.
After some investigation, we’ve identified more than twenty, that seem to slot into four broad categories.1) Property developer speak
• Portman Village – an attempt by local businesses to get more people to venture north of Marble Arch
• Connaught Village – the same, only the other side of Edgware road
• Seven Dials – the posher bit of Covent Garden
• Midtown – everything between the City and the West End, in what looks like a desperate attempt to attract Americans2) AbbReVos.
• NoHo – Fitzrovia
• SoBo – the Bricklayer’s Arms roundabout (it’s south of Borough, y’see)
• SoSho – south of Shoreditch
• NoDa and SoDa – north and south Dalston
• NoGo – our personal favourite, for a no-man’s-land somewhere north of Goldhawk Road3) Attempts to make desolate bits of marsh and industrial estate sound more appealing than they actually are
• Barking Riverside
• Barking Reach
• Havering Riverside
• Dagenham Reach4) Simple, shameless snobbery
• Blackheath Approach – Lewisham
• Lower Chelsea – Battersea
• Bowes and Bounds – Wood Green
• Herne Hill Borders – Brixton
• Steele’s Village – Chalk Farm (the residents association has stuck up banners and everything)
• ‘Highgate Slopes’ and ‘Archgate’ – ‘It isn’t Archway, honest’
Jan 4, 2012
"The Awkward Art of Neighborhood Naming" in Atlantic Cities
image from Flickr/macnewyork via the Atlantic article in questionI'm proud to say that I've been featured in a new article on The Atlantic's Cities blog. The article, "The Awkward Art of Neighborhood Naming" by Dena Levitz, focuses on questions of neighborhood identity in many American cities and especially the role of real-estate in sometimes (re)creating it.
In addition to having been one source for much of the information discussed in the article, I'm brought in discussing how local residents might feel about these changes and research on some of the implications that identity-driven gentrification can have for neighborhoods (on which, for the record, I'm not sure I'm quite accurately quoted but c'est la vie). The article is a great focus on this phenomenon, which I also explore in a forthcoming study of mine (see prev. post on the research). These themes are also addressed in studies of New York City by Phil Kasinitz, Malve von Hassel, Christopher Mele, and Richard Ocejo and in my own 2010 study (pdf) of the connection between transit planning and neighborhood identity. Thanks to Ms. Levitz for looking to me for my thoughts!
Dec 20, 2011
Spontaneous Interventions: Venice Architecture Biennale 2012
"In recent years, there has been a nascent movement of designers acting on their own initiative to solve problematic urban situations, creating new opportunities and amenities for the public. Provisional, improvisational, guerrilla, unsolicited, tactical, temporary, informal, unplanned, participatory, open-source—these are just a few of the words that have been used to describe this growing body of work. Spontaneous Interventions will frame an archive of compelling, actionable strategies, ranging from urban farms to guerilla bike lanes, temporary architecture to poster campaigns, urban navigation apps to crowdsourced city planning. In recent years, there has been a nascent movement of designers acting on their own initiative to solve problematic urban situations, creating new opportunities and amenities for the public. Provisional, improvisational, guerrilla, unsolicited, tactical, temporary, informal, unplanned, participatory, open-source—these are just a few of the words that have been used to describe this growing body of work. Spontaneous Interventions will frame an archive of compelling, actionable strategies, ranging from urban farms to guerilla bike lanes, temporary architecture to poster campaigns, urban navigation apps to crowdsourced city planning."

