Showing posts with label DIY urban design. Show all posts
Showing posts with label DIY urban design. Show all posts

Mar 3, 2014

From Parklets to People St.: City of L.A. Offers "DIY Kits" for Community Placemaking


One of the more important themes in my dissertation research on "do-it-yourself urban design" has turned out to be the increasingly obvious interaction between the tactics and aesthetics of informal, unauthorized community improvements and those of very official streetscape redesign efforts by some trend-setting major cities.

Probably the best example is the evolution, over a period of several years, of the once-clandestine Park(ing) Day movement into an international phenomenon (now often appropriated by local businesses and certified by authorities) and into the popular progressive planning trend of parklets. In San Francisco, where Park(ing) Day started with the radical architecture and design collective Rebar converting a single parking space into a temporary park in 2005, the idea was swiftly embraced by city officials and neighborhood boosters as a quick, cheap way to provide just the sort of novel public space amenities that hip young urbanites are looking for - some much larger than a parking space, some funded by major corporations, some designed by Rebar, now a successful agency with major civic clients. (The SF city planning department celebrates a variety of other "tactical interventions" as well). Many other cities have created official parklet programs too (I was interviewed in 2012 for an article about parklets in Chicago).


Well, the top-down embrace of DIY urbanism aesthetics continues at a fever pitch today with the City of Los Angeles's "People St." initiative. (Here's the post on the subject that caught my eye.) The City's Dept. of Transportation is officially asking citizens to use approved design "kits" to help create parklets, plazas, and bike corrals in order to "transform underused areas of L.A.'s largest public asset - our 7,500 miles of city streets - into active, vibrant, and accessible public space." Community groups can apply beginning today.

The City of Angels has fully embraced the language and the aesthetic of DIY and combined it with an official standardized process (plus a little cross-promotion thrown in for good measure).  As Victoria Young reports for PSFK:
The goal of the program is to improve the quality of life of Angelenos by providing a toolkit of cost-efficient design elements that can be quickly installed to help the city come alive with minimalist wood and steel planter boxes full of succulents, sleek picnic tables, and even GameTime exercise equipment [...]. Each kit contains packaged, required configurations for Plazas, Parklets, and Bike Corrals to choose from. Specifications provided in these documents simplify and automate the process, efficiently eliminating the need to reinvent the wheel for each project and streamlining the workflow with thoughtfully pre-approved design kits.
A parklet on Spring St. in Downtown Los Angeles. Source: Drew Ackerman, Flickr.
Some examples of the types of projects that People St. is promoting already exist in Los Angeles, including the above parklet, this bike corral in Highland Park, and the Sunset Triangle plaza in Silverlake. There's a lot to like here, whether or not one views this trend as DIY urban design "selling out" in a sense.  And the L.A. effort certainly responds to a need, not only for more public space and bicycle infrastructure at the expensive cars, but among citizens to make positive changes themselves. Several of my interviewees there said quite explicitly that they "wish the city would do it" so that they wouldn't have to. As one male cycling activist put it, "if there’s a place where we can do it […] up to spec and everything, we should be able to put it in ourselves."  This is pretty much exactly what LADOT is hoping. 

Of course, there are still reasons to keep a critical eye on these efforts. Not least is that, while they are touted as ways of expanding a city's public space (they are, after all, small parks), from the way the application/approval process is structured to the basic realities of contemporary urban economics, they can tend to wind up as little more than cute extensions of an adjacent business (which is often responsible for upkeep, bringing chairs in at night, etc). If something is essentially designed to look like outdoor seating for a sidewalk cafe, it may not appear at all welcoming or accessible to everyone no matter how many signs define its public-ness. And then there's the question of whether such hip improvements can be viewed as indicators (or even catalysts) of gentrification... but that's an argument for another day. For now, L.A.'s effort does at least seem to indicate a broadly positive (and refreshing) step among city officials and planners there, one that does justice to what Mayor Garcetti calls the "fundamental shift in how we make our city streets safer and more enjoyable."

Jan 24, 2014

"Do-it-Yourself Urban Design" in City & Community

My article, "Do-it-Yourself Urban Design: The Social Practice of Informal 'Improvement' Through Unauthorized Alteration," has been published in City & Community. It was published in early view in September 2013 actually, and will be in the next print issue (vol. 13, no. 1). 

The folks at the journal and the publisher, Wiley-Blackwell, have been super supportive and are making the article free (i.e. not behind the academic paywall) all year, so go download it here!: http://bit.ly/DIYurbandesign

Do-it-Yourself Urban Design
The Social Practice of Informal 'Improvement' Through Unauthorized Alteration
There are numerous ways in which people make illegal or unauthorized alterations to urban space. This study identifies and analyzes one that has been largely ignored in social science: explicitly functional and civic-minded informal contributions that I call “do-it-yourself urban design.” The research, which began as an investigation into more “traditional” nonpermissable alterations, uncovered these cases—from homemade bike lanes and street signs to guerrilla gardens and development proposals—that are gaining visibility in many cities, yet are poorly accounted for by existing perspectives in the literature. This article examines the existing theories and evidence from interviews and other fieldwork in 14 cities in order to develop the new analytical category of DIY urban design. I present findings on the creators of these interventions, on their motivations to “improve” the built environment where they perceive government and other development actors to be failing, and on the concentration of their efforts in gentrifying areas. This introduces the possibility of conflict and complicates their impact. I argue that DIY urban design has wide-ranging implications for both local communities and broader urban policy.

They also gave me the opportunity to create a 'video abstract' for the research, which you can see below. I'm a goober but it features some other friendly faces and familiar names behind the scenes. 


Thanks to everyone who helped with both the article and the video!

Oct 26, 2012

From the Streets to the Giardini: A Couple More Pieces About DIY Urban Design at the Venice Biennale

Just a note about two pieces I've published recently on some great blogs about the Spontaneous Interventions exhibition at the Venice Architecture Biennale and my participation in it. (See my previous post about the exhibition itself.)

First, several weeks ago, the good folks at GOOD were once again kind enough to run some words and pictures of mine, about the remarkable rise of this sort of 'spontaneous'/'tactical'/'diy' urbanism from the streets to the hallowed halls of the U.S. Pavilion at Venice. Here it is: Open-Source Urbanism: Venice Biennale Puts Spotlight on Renegade Designers. Got a nice short write-up by Dave Munson on his blog too.

Then, just the other day, I was honored to be asked to write a more L.A.-specific take on local involvement from the City of Angels in the Spontaneous Interventions show by Steetsblog Los Angeles. I love Streetsblog and have been a loyal reader for years, but this was my first opportunity to write a post for them. The article, L.A.'s Do-it-Yourself Urbanism Featured in International Architecture Exhibition, talks about work by James Rojas, Ken Mori and Jenny Lang, the L.A. Green Grounds project, and of course the city's amorphous "Department of DIY."

Sep 5, 2012

"Spontaneous Interventions: Design Actions for the Common Good"



As I've noted before, it's been amazing to be a part of the project curatorial team for the US pavilion at the Venice Architecture Biennale this year. The exhibition, Spontaneous Interventions: Design Actions for the Common Good, explores and showcases the movement toward innovative, ground-up, and often quite informal design contributions that people are making to their communities (overlapping in many ways with the phenomena I refer to in my research as DIY urban design). In addition to helping to find, review, select, and write up statements for the featured projects, I co-edited the exhibition catalog (a special issue of Architect magazine) with the pavilion commissioner and head curator, Cathy Lang Ho.

Well after 10 months of work, it was incredible to find myself in Venice's Giardini last week for the opening of the Biennale. Just seeing the installation itself in physical form was wonderful, truly exceeding my own high hopes for it - cheers to the team on the ground in Venice for the past month installing it all (as well as keeping the space running smoothly during the opening days).


The American pavilion is essentially four big galleries arranged in a horse-shoe around a front courtyard (above; a small central hall behind the columns pictured connects the second and third galleries, so there are two on each side). For our installation, the galleries are filled with 124 hanging banners, each one featuring one of the participating projects. (The exhibition website also features the content from each of the 124 banners.)

On entering, one actually sees the back of the banners (see photo at top), which have colorful 'bar codes' indicating the different thematic areas the intervention speaks to (community, information, environment, etc.). On the fronts of these are the descriptions of the projects. And, when a visitor pulls down on a banner, a pulley raises a block on the opposite wall showing the problem the project addresses:




On the floor is a winding timeline of urbanism, broken into four chunks by room, running from the "first city" (c. 7500 BC) through the rise of urban planning and design in the 19th century to recent things like Critical Mass and pop-up parklets.


In the central hall area, a video montage featuring interviews with a number of our participants plays on a large screen.


And finally, in the outdoor courtyard, a vibrant interactive public space was created by the New York design group Interboro. It features a raised platform for sitting, mingling and for presentations, and a sunken area for sitting, interacting, or participating in activities, all stocked with bright orange plush cubes - which can be used for sitting, or for playing. The space was programmed with panel discussions and workshops for much of the day, and was otherwise usually alive with children (and adults) interacting with the cubes and the space.


The exhibition, the installation, and the catalog are all very much what I hoped they would be, and a wonderful realization of the ideas that Cathy Ho and so many others had in doing this rather non-traditional exhibition. And don't just take my word for it - I'm proud to say that Spontaneous Interventions has already received many accolades, and on Wednesday we were awarded a relatively rare Special Mention by the Biennale judges (with the top Golden Lion award going to the excellent Japanese pavilion). "This interactive installation impressed the Jury with its celebration of the power of individuals to change society in small but effective ways," the judges wrote of the US pavilion, adding: "The unpretentiously simple presentation was a delight.”

The exhibition was realized by a talented team of hardworking individuals (many unpaid), every one of whom was excited and passionate about the project and its subject. I couldn't be more proud to have been a small part of this.

Jul 25, 2012

Place-Making with James Rojas... in New York!

From East L.A. to the East Village, urbanist and planner James Rojas is in NYC this month for engagements at Pratt and elsewhere. He's also been taking his Place-It! workshops all around the city! Last night I was able to attend one myself, held in Tompkins Square Park as part of the Urban SPACEship meet-up group.

The event was great, with dozens of people assembled on the grass in Tompkins Square. James explained his method, to inspire everyday community members to think about their placemaking ideals without the restrictions of planner-speak and bureaucratic guidelines. Then we all sat down with our construction paper and hundreds of unique, abstractly shaped toys and objects to design "our ideal childhood place."








































I created something (below) inspired by the town of Watford, Hertfordshire, and especially its enormous wooded greenspace, Cassiobury Park. This park, a couple of blocks from my grandparents' house in this London suburb in which I spent much of my childhood, is the place that always comes immediately to mind when I think of childhood and idyllic places. Together with its surrounding walkable streets, shops, and train access, it is - oddly though it may sound to some who know the city and its rougher edges - pretty ideal in terms of urban design.


Next, we were tasked to get into groups of five or six and create a vision for improving Tompkins Square itself. My group went with a board game-inspired theme (below) and many of the groups emphasized water (as had many childhood places in the previous exercise).




All in all a great experience and demonstration of the potential in the 'Place-It' method. Most importantly, it got a wide variety of New Yorkers talking about place in really free and creative ways.

Jun 9, 2012

Exploring East L.A. with James Rojas


I spent last week in Los Angeles, finishing up the last of my dissertation research there and visiting friends. I interviewed some fascinating people, from high-ups in the departments of transportation and city planning to landscape architecture luminaries such as Mia Lehrer. Another real highlight, however, was meeting the great James Rojas (of Place It and 'Latino Urbanism' fame) and enjoying a personal guided tour of his East L.A. stomping grounds.

Even for someone who lived in the city for seven years, who prides himself on knowing the city and having explored many of its farthest corners, hidden gems, and quiet neighborhoods, a tour like this was absolutely amazing.

James picked me up in Boyle Heights near Mariachi Plaza - long home to mariachis waiting for work and recently home to a shiny new subway station. From there were headed straight to food, sharing an amazing meal at El Tapayac, as he put it, a "real old Chicano place."


One of the most interesting aspects of the 'Latino Urbansim' James showed to me is the spread of "parking lot shrines" throughout East L.A.  The first below here is the parking lot at  El Tapayac, the second at El Mercado, the massive market we visited next.



After the mercado (modeled on the one in Gudalajara), we embarked on an epic drive through various parts of unincorporated East L.A. itself, from side streets to main shopping boulevards. James pointed out many examples of the prevalent spatial trends that have been the subject of his research since his days at MIT. These themes include the do-it-yourself nature of place-making, the reappropriation of existing forms into more resonant ones, and the incorporation of Latino symbolism into the built environment.



We also stopped by Our Lady of Guadalupe Sanctuary Church, modeled on (but a miniature version of) the twin-towered cathedrals of Mexico's great cities.


Knowing my love for graffiti, James made the final stop on the tour an especially awesome one: the underbelly of the East L.A. interchange.  Under the confluence of three major interstates, behind some easily negotiated fencing and wedged between a scrap yard and the Los Angeles River, sits a sort of graffiti mecca. It is notable in the same vain as Five Pointz in Queens, if considerably more off the beaten path and certainly not quite as much of a destination (for tourists or apparently for bombers; its isn't nearly as wall-to-wall plastered in street art). It's an amazing urban space...




After climbing back out from under the interchange, we concluded our tour with a drive back across the River and into downtown, where James kindly dropped me back at another subway stop. I couldn't be more grateful to him for the amazing afternoon and incredible tour.


Thanks James, see you soon!

Apr 17, 2012

"Lefebvre and Whyte Hit the Streets"

I had a great time at the 14th annual Chicago Ethnography Conference last week at UIC. I saw some great talks and some great friends, and got to give a paper in a neat session on Public Spaces. The paper, "Lefebvre and Whyte Hit the Streets," presents some new findings from my dissertation research on "DIY Urban Design" and is sort of a first attempt at a 'free-standing' article/chapter to come out of it. Here's the abstract:

Lefebvre and Whyte Hit the Streets
The Diffusion of Scholarly Urbanism and the Rise of the Informal Urban Designer

There are numerous ways in which people make illegal or unauthorized alterations to urban space, its uses, or meanings. This paper is based on my research into a particular type of spatial intervention: creative, highly localized, and largely anonymous practices aimed explicitly at “improving” particular aspects of the built environment without permission. Examples include people painting their own crosswalks and bicycle lanes, gardening vacant lots and public spaces, building and installing benches and other street furniture, or creating faux-official signage to promote desired civic improvements or commemorate unheralded events – what I call “do-it-yourself urban design.” We all have our assumptions about the meanings of these types of things, who makes them, why, and where, and they raise questions of context, rights, responsibilities, and perhaps unintended consequences. To that end, this paper presents one of the more unexpected and potentially significant findings - the degree to which many members of this group of informal placemakers are in fact informed by quite sophisticated knowledge of planning, design, and academic urbanism. Building from qualitative fieldwork and interviews with individuals in nine cities, I show how the ideas of professional planning and design and scholarly urban theory feature in the work of do-it-yourself urban designers. I argue that this knowledge inspires their actions, informs their justifications, and produces a self-reflexivity on their parts that at once emboldens them and raises personal ethical dilemmas about unintended consequences.

Feb 26, 2012

AAG 2012

The annual Association of American Geographers conference is in full swing here in New York City. I'm excited to be in the program twice, for both a panel discussion this afternoon and a paper session on Tuesday.

This afternoon I'm really looking forward to the panel on Parsing the Politics and Practice of 'DIY' that I organized with my friends and colleagues Brian Hracs of the University of Toronto and Uppsala University, and Michael Seman of U.T. Arlington. As we write in the abstract, the panel will "bring together an interdisciplinary group of scholars to discuss the evolution of the term and its value as a topic of conceptual and empirical inquiry. Drawing on studies of music, art, fashion, cycling culture and urban revitalization the panelists will unpack the intersections between alternative identities and practices and how activities associated with D.I.Y. shape, and are shaped by, local spaces and scenes." Our excellent panel also includes: Patrick Adler (UCLA), Alison Bain (York), Dan Campo (Morgan State), Doreen Jakob (Exeter), and Johan Jansson (Uppsala).

Then, on Tuesday morning, I'll be presenting my most recent findings from my dissertation research on DIY urban design in talk entitled "Don't Wait for Anybody to Give you Permission: Unauthorized Urban Design 'Contributions' in the Contemporary City". It will be part of a great-sounding session on "Locating Alternative Geographies Through the Spatial Imaginary" organized by Ingrid Butler and Asha Best. The abstract can be found here.

Feb 24, 2012

El Urbanismo Informal de Ciudad Mexico

I had the extreme pleasure of spending a couple of weeks in Mexico City this month, working with the rainwater harvesting group Isla Urbana in the city's Tlalpan delegacion and conducting research on DIY urban design all over town. It is an amazing place to do this research, because the range of informal urban design interventions here is staggering, on a scale to match the immensity and diversity of this amazing city.

On the one hand, as a dynamic and international 'global city,' hip cultural scenes and world-class architecture and design thinking set the stage for excellent examples of the sort of high-concept unauthorized improvements seen in L.A., Toronto, and London. Groups like Haz Ciudad - formed in large part by professional designers and planners - have embraced the concept of 'wikiciudad', the idea that anyone can edit and modify cities (see this excellent piece by my friend Jimena).

Here, Haz Ciudad's "wikilane" near the Mercado Jamaica in del. Venustiano Carranza has stayed put for months and become part of the fabric of everyday life in the neighborhood.
At the same time, however, in keeping with its duel identity as very much a southern, 'developing world' capital, Mexico City also essentially runs on informal urbanism.

Here, a couple of community members simply repave their street in a hillside neighborhood of Xochimilco. And below, an informal settlement and bodega constructed along a public bike path in Tlalpan.

Muchísimas gracias a todos en Isla Urbana y mis increíbles guías turísticos y compañeros de ciclismo Jimena y Oscar! Hasta la próxima!

(These are just a few favorites. If you feel like sifting through the less relevant stuff, please check out this album for much more DF.)

Dec 20, 2011

Spontaneous Interventions: Venice Architecture Biennale 2012

I'm honored to announce that I'll be working with the Institute for Urban Design and a team of incredible curators on the American representation at the 13th Venice Biennale of Architecture in 2012. Sponsored in part by the Department of State's Bureau of Education and Cultural Affairs, the U.S. pavilion's theme will be "Spontaneous Interventions: Design Actions for the Common Good" - a topic very close to my heart. From the online statement:
"In recent years, there has been a nascent movement of designers acting on their own initiative to solve problematic urban situations, creating new opportunities and amenities for the public. Provisional, improvisational, guerrilla, unsolicited, tactical, temporary, informal, unplanned, participatory, open-source—these are just a few of the words that have been used to describe this growing body of work. Spontaneous Interventions will frame an archive of compelling, actionable strategies, ranging from urban farms to guerilla bike lanes, temporary architecture to poster campaigns, urban navigation apps to crowdsourced city planning. In recent years, there has been a nascent movement of designers acting on their own initiative to solve problematic urban situations, creating new opportunities and amenities for the public. Provisional, improvisational, guerrilla, unsolicited, tactical, temporary, informal, unplanned, participatory, open-source—these are just a few of the words that have been used to describe this growing body of work. Spontaneous Interventions will frame an archive of compelling, actionable strategies, ranging from urban farms to guerilla bike lanes, temporary architecture to poster campaigns, urban navigation apps to crowdsourced city planning."
As a project manager I've been working with Cathy Lang Ho, Mimi Zeiger, and Anne Guiney and Brendan Crain at the Institute on cataloging instances of informal and 'tactical' urban design intervention across the country. In the coming weeks and months we'll be selecting projects to highlight in different ways in Venice and working with designers, artists and curators to realize the pavilion. A full, free-standing webpage with lots more info and an interactive blog platform is coming soon. In the meantime, check out http://www.ifud.org/venice/.

Nov 9, 2011

Street Art & Magical Urbanism in Japanese Cities


A wonderful article by a_small_lab's Chris Berthelson in This Big City last month got me thinking again about a subject that's long been dear to me - informal urbanism in Japanese cities!

Chris's piece, "The Non-Intentional Landscape of Tokyo," argues that part of the magic of that city is not only its relative geographical centerless-ness, but an essentially "decentralized" way of growing, managing, inhabiting, and relating to itself. Complex redefinitions of public and private space are better understood as interconnected constellations of "scattered uchi." As he writes, "Once thus comprehended, Tokyo’s non-intentional landscape has the appearance of purposefulness in a system which is not purposefully constructed simply because purposeless is in its very nature transitory."

Well this post of mine is not really a response to this lovely bit of urban critical thought, but simply a fun reaction to it - it seems a good enough excuse to put up a few images from my last trip to Japan.

On the left, some sort of book exchange sponsored by Tokyo Metro; right, a classic example of pot gardening in public space in Kyoto. Below, graffiti along the canal in the Nakameguro area. Click for larger images.


Oct 9, 2011

Place-Making at Occupy Wall Street


I was down at Occupy Wall Street a few days last week, hanging out in Zuccotti Park, speaking with people camped out and working there. It's true that they're mostly a somewhat disorganized group camped out in a concrete plaza for a variety of reasons (crust punks, politicians, long-time activists, laid off Wall St. types, union members, long-term homeless) but the media has it wrong that they don't know what they stand for or that they aren't committed to it.


I especially enjoyed checking out many of the DIY amenities that have been created there, from free food and clothing to a massive library, grey water recycling system, technology center, and even a barber! A few images...




Aug 20, 2011

DIY Urban Design at ASA - Las Vegas

I'll be presenting my research on do-it-yourself urban design tomorrow morning at the American Sociological Association's annual conference here in Las Vegas. I'll be joining a panel of fascinating-sounding papers in the regular session on Popular Culture, organized by Dr. Terry McDonnell with Dr. Dustin Kidd presiding. Below is a revised abstract for the paper , the circulation version of which can be found here (pdf).


Do-It-Yourself Urban Design

Making Local Improvements Through Unauthorized Alterations of Urban Space
There are numerous ways in which people make illegal or unauthorized alterations to urban space, its uses, or meanings. This paper presents a particular type of unauthorized intervention, which I distinguish from other “traditional” forms of illegal spatial intervention (graffiti, political occupation, etc.), and which has not been described in previous research: creative, highly localized, and largely anonymous practices that are aimed explicitly at “improving” the built environment of local communities – in other words, “do-it-yourself” urban design. In painting their own crosswalks and bicycle lanes, building and installing benches and other street furniture, or creating faux-official signage to promote desired civic improvements or commemorate unheralded events, people are responding to perceived inadequacies in their communities and taking design responsibilities into their own hands; even small-scale acts of aesthetic alteration assert a vision of the city as open to individual “beautification.” Building from qualitative fieldwork and interviews with individuals in London, Los Angeles, New York, Pittsburgh, Toronto, and Vancouver, I discuss the implications of these practices for understanding the contemporary city and contentious politics and raise questions of rights, responsibilities and perhaps unintended consequences.

Aug 17, 2011

Aspirational DIY Urbanism in Phoenix

Came across this wall on N. 4th St. in Downtown Phoenix today. Had been to the area before on previous visits (it's right near the Roosevelt Row arts district) but this was new to me.

(click to read sign in bigger image)

I wound up meeting the woman behind the project and "Rogue Green" just a couple blocks away in a cafe on 5th, seems it's been a great success. You can learn more about the project at http://roguegreen.blogspot.com/

Here's Brian having a go at it:

Jul 13, 2011

Touring Toronto with the Urban Repair Squad


I was up in Toronto last month for the Experience the Creative Economy conference at the UofT's Martin Prosperity Institute (see earlier post). While I was in town I had the honor and privilege of taking an impromptu guided tour of D.I.Y. urbanism in the city with a spokesperson for the acclaimed local bike lane champions and all-around unauthorized do-gooders The Urban Repair Squad.

Anti-bike signs on the TTC were replaced with a more bike-friendly message (above), and even some classic pieces, like these bike-lane commentaries and "pothole onomatopoeia" are a bit worn down but still doing their part.


As my URS liaison explained, "the group kind of fulfills an official function [...] Above all it asks questions about how urban design is used, and what it is used for."

We also saw some fantastic street art:

Above, Posterchild stencil and others. Below, a piece by Poser (is it?) in Kensington Market, and a slightly disregarded Banksy in an alley. (Click for larger images)