Thoughts (sociological and geographical)
on urban space, identity, culture, and design.
Aug 17, 2010
On "Fringe" Gentrification Processes in a Neighborhood in Transition
The Edge of the Island: Neighborhood Identity and Evolving Communities in 'Liminal Places'
This paper examines the contemporary processes at work in urban areas without clear spatial identities that are simultaneously facing the challenges of cultural change and gentrification. I do so through the close analysis of one such ‘liminal place’ on Chicago’s West Side. I use the phrase ‘community on the edge of the island’ to describe the area, inspired by an interviewee who referred to the tenuous search for a sort of ideal bohemian hipness as the need to stay as “close to the edge of the island” as possible without actually leaving it. Making use of ethnographic and geographic field work in the area and a review of relevant literature, the study examines how neighborhood identity is imagined, projected and negotiated by different actors, and the role of socio-economic processes, institutions, and spatial histories and mythologies themselves in these processes. First, I discuss the idea of a place without a name and introduce the area that I call Edgetown. This is followed by a more detailed analysis of the transitional nature of the area, leading in turn to the core discussion of the communities – both long-established and newly forming – that are to be found there and the specific time and space that make the “the edge of the island” such a revealing subject for understanding current neighborhood change.
Jul 24, 2010
BGP Getting Some Cool Attention
Here's a few other 'back garden projects' I just found on the web:
May 26, 2010
The Potential for 'Community Supportive' Transit
By taking local identity into account, cities can not only foster a more transit-supportive community, but actually build more community-supportive transit. For cities like Los Angeles, trying to address recognized deficiencies in both mass transportation and community identity and cohesion, recognizing this connection could be crucial.
Here's the abstract for the article. It can be accessed here (or just email me for a copy).
Rail Transit Identification and Neighborhood Identity: Exploring the Potential for 'Community-Supportive Transit'
The preservation and promotion of neighbourhood identity is important in contemporary cities. Los Angeles, long known for its lack of both effective mass transit and, separately, local identity and cohesion among its neighbourhoods, is currently working to address each of these issues, yet little attention has been paid to the possibility that the two can be directly related. This paper investigates how rail transit line identification and station-naming decisions are not only important to community members but can have an impact on the neighbourhood identity. After introducing these ideas with the case of the identification of the Metro 'Expo Line' in LA, the paper turns to a comparison of naming logics for other local institutions and other major transit systems, arguing that cities could benefit from considering 'community supportive' transit design that promotes local identity in addition to more pragmatic wayfinding concerns.
Douglas, Gordon C. C. "Transit Identification and Neighborhood Identity: Exploring the Potential for 'Community-Supportive Transit,'" Journal of Urban Design, vol. 15, no. 2, May 2010. 175-193.
Apr 7, 2010
The Back Garden Project
http://www.good.is/series/back-garden-project/
I'll be using the blog to track the adventure of clearing, planning, planting, and nurturing this garden over the coming months. Check it out.
Mar 25, 2010
Lefebvre's Theory of Moments
Lefebvre emphasized the value of criticism at the level of the 'everyday' and essential for the revolutionary project and saw the practice of critique as itself emancipatory and something we might all engage in. How exactly this is to be accomplished is another question, however, an ambiguity developed in fits and starts over a long career. I'm working on a more thorough review of these ideas, but one of the most interesting yet at the same time frustratingly elusive concepts is that of the "moment," something that reveals the “breadth and magnificence of the possibilities” inherent in the existential ennui of daily life (1947 [2008], p 229).
Built out of the ideas of Leibniz, Hegel, and Marx (see note below),“moments” are strenuously intangible when variously described by Lefebvre, but the important components can be drawn out. The concept first turns up in a somewhat overly-nostalgic discussion of ancient and peasant cultures that Lefebvre idealizes as having been extant prior to alienation (which was to his mind a sort of historically progressing process tied to modernity, capitalism, and the commodity form). “Mystics and metaphysicians,” he argues, “used to acknowledge that everything in life revolved around exceptional moments… These moments were festivals: festivals of the mind or the heart, public or intimate festivals” (p 250).
Moments are first discussed at length in Lefebvre's 1959 autobiographical work La Somme et le reste (from which I've recently translated a seemingly-important untranslated chapter), mostly as a concept that he admits he had long struggled to define and finally described unsatisfactorily through examples of what he calls “partial totalities”: love, play, struggle, creative activity (1959 [1989], pp 235, 237).
Two years later, Lefebvre offered a “theory of moments” in which the moment is defined as “the attempt to achieve the total realization of a possibility” (1961 [2008], p 348), and is again exemplified as love and play, and as festival. Lefebvre adds years later that some moments “are seeking to shatter the everydayness trapped in generalized exchange,” and seek to “transform daily life through poetry” (1981 [2008], pp 57, 172). A somewhat clearer summary of the idea is offered by Merrifield (2006, p 29): “Just as alienation reflected an absence, a dead moment empty of critical content, the Lefebvrian moment signified a presence, a fullness, alive and connected.” While sloppily defined by Lefebvre, the idea of the moment is important to his theory, a shared, imprecise-but-mutually recognizable meme of experience that serves as a potentially liberating exception to the everyday that is nonetheless born of the everyday.
Still, the search for the possible via the festival or the moment are not ‘revolutionary’ in themselves for Lefebvre. As others have pointed out (Trebitsch, 2002 [2008]; Merrifield, 2006; 2008) the Lefebvrian moment can be seen as somewhat analogous to (and even inspirational of) “the situation” of Guy Debord and the Situationists, yet Lefebvre disputed the idea that simply subverting the everyday will lead to consciousness of ‘real life.’ Lefebvre even seems sometimes unsure of the chances for success even through his own philosophy of praxis, turning away from the emancipatory potential of his quotidien critique at times to a more skeptical tone and language suggesting the unlikelihood of the necessary revolutionary preconditions. The possibilities for clarity and critique (and thus transformation) are always present in Lefebvre’s theory, but his optimism for them is inconsistent. Particularly in his earlier work, they are fleeting, tentative, beyond the reach of most of us most of the time, confined to “certain privileged moments of lucidity” while “most people remain imprisoned within narrow, out-of-date frames of reference” (2008a, p 247).
Furthermore, Lefebvre argues that “Consciousness must be gained over and over again through action and struggle as well as through organizations whose role is to penetrate everyday life” (p 151). Through the critique of everyday life, the individual can learn “certain infinitely delicate but efficacious techniques which will give him active power over himself qua content” (p 248), but “the problem remains: how can the ‘masses’ – whether masses of moments of masses of human beings – ‘participate’ in a total vision” (p 250). Lefebvre thus explains and essentially accommodates for the lack of socialist revolutionary transformation at once, putting the ideal ‘total moment’ on “a distant horizon beyond our present vision” (2008d, p 66) and emphasizing the value of seemingly minor, personal moments whereby the transformation of everyday life might still be slowly affected.
*Note: Merrifield (2006, p 29) succinctly describes the significance of “moments” for Hegel and Marx: “All dialectical movement progressed through different moments: moments of skeptical, negative consciousness defined history for Hegel; moments of contradictory unity defined and structured capitalism for Marx. All reality for both thinkers was momentary, transient, in motion, in fluid state, whether as an idea or as material reality.”
Works cited:
Lefebvre, Henri. 1947 (2008). Critique of Everyday Life Vol. I: Introduction, 2nd Ed., trans. J. Moore. London and New York: Verso.
Lefebvre, Henri. 1957 (2008). “Foreword to the Second Edition” in H. Lefebvre, The Critique of Everyday Life Vol. I: Introduction, 2nd Ed., trans. J. Moore. London and New York: Verso.
Lefebvre, Henri. 1961 (2008). Critique of Everyday Life Vol. II: Foundations for a Sociology of the Everyday, trans. J. Moore. London and New York: Verso.
Lefebvre, Henri. 1981 (2008). Critique of Everyday Life Vol. III: From Modernity to Modernism, trans. G. Elliot. London and New York: Verso.
Merrifield, Andy. 2006. Henri Lefebvre: A Critical Introduction. New York and London: Routledge.
Merrifield, Andy. 2008. “Lefebvre and Debord: A Faustian Fusion,” in K. Goonewardena, et al. eds., Space, Difference, Everyday Life: Reading Henri Lefebvre. New York and London: Routledge.
Trebitsch, Michel. 2002 (2008). “Preface: The Moment of Radical Critique,” in H. Lefebvre, Critique of Everyday Life Vol. II: Foundations for a Sociology of the Everyday, trans. G. Elliot. London and New York: Verso.
Nov 11, 2009
Why Save a Community Garden?
http://www.good.is/post/why-save-a-community-garden/
Thanks AP!
Oct 23, 2009
The Production and Consumption of Glamour

The article begins by questioning the (mis)assumption that LA is "just glamour," defined by Hollywood or somehow more culturally insubstantial than other major cities, but then looks closely at the important role that glamour does play in urban development.
'For Gundle and Castelli (2006: 151), “In all the great cities, it was the rich, the aristocrats of money, who shone most brightly.” Yet in Los Angeles, rather than the poor looking in from the streets at brightly lit shops and amusements, it is the rich who look down from their dark and isolated canyon homes on the billions of lights of the teaming city of the poor.'In Part I, "Glamour in History and in Hollywood," I build from historical and critical work by Hortense Powdermaker (1950), Ronald Davis (1993), Gundle & Castelli (2006) and others, using the social and spatial history of Hollywood itself as a model for understanding the different phases that the concept and actualization of glamour have gone through in L.A.
'Downtown became a center not only of financial wealth, but glamorous entertainment and culture, and sparkling architectural landmarks hosting museums and performing arts. The allure of urbanity and bohemia stretched into Downtown too, as well as the hipster meccas of Echo Park and other ‘Eastside’ neighborhoods to the northeast. And in Hollywood, a massive revitalization effort saw a decline in vice and the Disneyfication of the area’s glamorous landmarks, culminating with the massive Hollywood and Highland development, an architectural ode to Hollywood glamour, mass transit, and rampant consumption all at once.'Part 2, "The Many Glamours of the Postmetropolis," then looks at the ways that the idea and the aesthetics of different types of glamour are actively produced and consumed as part of the city's culture, politics, architecture, and industry. I propose three ideal-typical categories of glamour as heuristics: the "Status as Glamour" of Bunker Hill, fine art, and wealth, the "Glitz as Glamour" of Hollywood plasticity, cars, and showbiz, and (Ć la Richard Lloyd) the "Grit as Glamour" of Eastside gentrification and downtown art scenes.
'The many diverse glamours to be found in Los Angeles today: from the film industry to finance, the allure of haute cuisine to the chrome of Latino car culture, the manufactured spectacle of absurdist architecture to the hippest loft conversion.'It is clear that to even begin to fully appreciate the role of glamour in 21st Century Los Angeles, as both cultural meme and economic engine, one must look well beyond Hollywood and the traditional power structures that shaped the city during the 20th.
To take another example discussed in the paper, while Latinos were historically "hardly thought to be the height of glamour" in Hollywood (Wood, 2002), the real glamour of Latino L.A. is found in the varied popular aesthetics of this diverse group, from quinceaƱera celebrations and the spiritual iconography (drawn from Catholicism and Chicano legend alike) visible in votive candles and artwork, to contemporary fashion, murals, performance spectacles, and of course cars. (What could be more glamorous than sexy, attention-grabbing low-riders souped up with loud ‘cherry bomb’ mufflers and dramatic paint jobs?) And one cannot forget the role played by thousands of Latinos in the physical production of glamor commodities, from garment manufacturing and entertainment-related service work to performance, design, production etc. in the culture industries.
'The potential is staggering for different cultural conceptions of glamour. In a city as diverse and disconnected as Los Angeles today, we should not expect to find anything less than hundreds of definitions.'I focus not only on how these different glamours play with cultural identities and the urban landscape, but how they are integrally tied to the production of capital and scenes of consumption.
I demonstrate throughout how culture becomes commodity in the city. The three ideal-typical glamours, and their physical manifestations in the city, are valuable tools for understanding this potentially powerful concept, and all suggest the direct link betweenglamour and consumption. Whether seeing the philharmonic or a Lakers game, coming home from a punk show to a newly-converted loft, or going to see a movie at the Chinese Theater (or a theater in China), glamour is commoditized.
“Any theory of glamour,” write Gundle and Castelli (2006: 8-9), “would have to take account of its imaginative appeal, seductiveness and artificiality. It would also need to refer to persistent class divisions, the alienation of modern capitalism and the frustrations of consumer culture.” But, as Paul Willis (1990: 21) explains, “human consumption does not simply repeat the relations of production – and whatever cynical motives lie behind them. Interpretation, symbolic action and creativity are part of consumption.” Perhaps it is this aspect of glamour production and consumption that really makes L.A. so glamorous today.
To read the full article (including references for citations above), visit http://www.monu.org/mudot2/GDG_whatis.pdf. Douglas, Gordon C. C. "What is Glamour? The Production & Consumption of a Working Aesthetic," MU-DOT: the Magazine for Urban Documentation Opinion and Theory, no. 2, Aug. 2009. 44-63
Jul 18, 2009
Observations on the banlieux of Tokyo
Ultimately this gives way to more expected - if always quite Japanese - 'suburban' communities, notable mainly for their greenery and engagement with agriculture both in and around them.
Mar 29, 2009
The CTA Gold Line?
Yours truly has been working with a Chicago social justice group called SOUL (Southsiders Organized for Unity and Liberation) on various things pertaining to a "more equitable" olympics, should Chicago win the bid. Many are outright opposed to it, but there's an effort to at least make sure that there are protections for the poor/homeless and long-term advantages for the south side if it DOES have to happen. One of things they're fighting for is the so-called Gold Line (see for example http://bit.ly/fxsEi), basically converting one of the southeast Metra Electric tracks to a regular rapid transit service (run by CTA or Metra, we don't care) with frequent trains, CTA fares and easy transfers, etc. Anyway, I am proud to be responsible for this nifty map at right (click here for larger image: http://home.uchicago.edu/~Sep 6, 2006
Corporate Graffiti is Wack - an invitation to discuss

...but I sure have (oh yeah, the chop shop on Lincoln Blvd = major hipster hot spot). But seriously they're all over Venice, Silverlake, SaMo and also apparently the Mission, South Street, Williamsburg, etc.
Suspicious that they all popped up so fast? Suspicious of their presence on otherwise graffiti-free walls, their ad-agency-esque saturday morning appeal, and the fact that they all include kids with fucking PSPs in their hands?
That's right. If this sounds a little bit like a marketing campaign to you, you're right! These are ads. They are corporate graffiti. Pieces commissioned by Sony's ad agency, thrown up by Sony employees, on walls that have already been cleared and paid for by Sony.
This isn't just lame (which it is). And it isn't just an unoriginal and ulitmately kinda sad attempt by a giant corporation to be hip and down and fresh and chill, in the parlance of our times (which it also is). It begs the question of what is graffiti/street art, and what does it mean.
I argue that street art, in all its myriad forms, from glass scratching to poster art to ad busting, is about popular expression in the public space. Critically, it is about in some way affecting the panoptic and hyper-commercialized urban built environment with personal expression and even resistance. It is one (of many) ways that people (aka, the people) can continue to create truly popular (aka, 'of the people') culture in our overly commoditized and 'pop' culture and reclaim public spaces.
Corporate 'graff' contradicts these in that it is not of the people (it is of the corporation, the culture industry, the 'man') and, as long as its paid for as an advertisement it is sure as hell not reclaiming any public space (but rather is commoditizing even more of it). (There is room for debate about whether IBM's illegal 2001 Linux tagging campaign is equally dubious).
Now, according to Ryan Singel's great piece in Wired (to whom also go photo creds), Sony believes they are totally rad and that it, like, totally makes sense man because the PSP is a fuckin "disrupter product." Yeah man! Fuck yeah, I can fuckin watch a movie on the bus! Take that MTA, take that Hollywood! Lets disrupt some shit!
Actually, though... an interesting point. Can portable products, even if they are corporate commodities, offer users some greater level of popular agency? As Sony spokeswoman Molly Smith explains in Singel's piece, "With PSP being a portable product, our target is what we consider to be urban nomads, people who are on the go constantly." So at this level, it isn't really any more empowering than a laptop, but perhaps the potential is there...
What if some future PSP could allow users to leave messages, pics or 'virtual tags' in the ether over certain places for other users to pick up (see: urban tapestries), or allow them to hack digital advertisements in the world around them, or even just hack the net. Certainly products that leave a great deal of control, meaning and usage up to the whim of the everyday user have popular potential.
But Sony isn't there yet, nor in my humble opinion is any corporate advertising, whether it looks like graffiti or looks like a bilboard.
The ad wizzards who think they get it and love Sony's approach betray just how out of touch they are with statements like this, quoted in the Wired article, regarding the perceived backlash against Sony's work: "I wonder if that's a San Francisco phenomenon," Fawkes said. "I know there's a certain mindset there." No shit. Lets show 'em there's a "certain mindset" in lotsa places.

Originally posted elsewhere by me in December 2005
Read the Wired article, with more pics, by Ryan Singel here.
Check out 'Social Matrices: A Think Tank for Culture' here.
Check out Sony's PSP website here.